Lessons learned from Beijing’s 7-year Emission Trading Scheme

As the follow-up of the case study on Beijing’s pilot emission trading scheme (ETS), the Asia Low Emission Development Strategies Partnership (ALP) and the ICLEI East Asia Secretariat co-hosted a dedicated online peer-learning session for the case, inviting participants from the ALP member countries— including India, Sri Lanka, Malaysia, and Mongolia— to learn about Beijing’s experience in developing and operating its ETS and actively exchange thoughts with the representative from the Beijing Municipal Ecology and Environment Bureau.

At the invitation of ICLEI East Asia, Ms. Chunmei Li, Deputy Chief of the Science & Technology and International Cooperation Division (Climate Affairs Division) of the Beijing Municipal Ecology and Environment Bureau, presented the experience and lessons learned from the city’s pilot Emission Trading Scheme (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Beijing ETS’) during the webinar on 11 March 2021.

As one of the 7 national pilots, Beijing established its ETS almost from scratch. By borrowing foreign practices and localizing them for the development of a local policy mechanism, as well as legal and regulatory frameworks, Beijing officially launched its ETS in November 2013. The city’s successful experience has been channeled into the incremental development of China’s national ETS, which is expected to be launched in 2021.

Beijing City / Source: N509FZ at WikiMedia Commons

In the session, Li presented the corresponding legislation and regulations Beijing has enacted for its ETS, which have proven to be a pillar of market operation and liquidity. As one of the two cities among all Chinese ETS pilots to have enforced municipal ordinances in regulating enterprises’ emissions, the legal bidding penalties for non-compliances set in Beijing have urged entities to actively seek carbon credits in the market. She also emphasized the importance of engagement and communication with enterprises when initiating the scheme, and shared how the Chinese Capital has earned buy-in from relevant stakeholders.

In addition, Li reminds that city-wide and sectoral GHGs inventories play a critical role in establishing a reasonable and effective carbon allowance allocation mechanism. For instance, to reflect the characteristics of each sector, Beijing has developed nearly 20 guidelines regarding sectors’ allowance allocation and deployed three methods in distributing the allowances. Accordingly, each industry has its dedicated Monitoring, Reporting and Verification (MRV) system.

The Beijing ETS has also played a role in encouraging residents to adopt zero-carbon lifestyles. Citizens of Beijing can participate in the emission trading market by selling the carbon credits they earned through using public transport. Such transactions are carried out through an intermediate entity which collects credits from citizens and puts them on the open carbon market.

Participants were particularly keen to know the challenges Beijing has faced and how to overcome them. Li pointed out that the lack of a shared understanding of the ETS between the private sector and government agencies in the early stage had been a significant barrier. While businesses were not familiar with the concept of emission trading, government officials had little knowledge about financial markets. The Municipality, therefore, initiated a series of intensive capacity building activities for all stakeholders, where experts from home and abroad were invited to provide know-how supporting Beijing to set up the scheme.

Beijing at COP.png 
Representative from Beijing (third from the left) was invited to share the city's successful experience of
establishing and operating the ETS at a COP25 side event in 2019.

After going through 3 different stages of implementation over the course of 7 years, the Beijing ETS now has over 900 liable entities from 7 sectors — electricity, heat, cement, petrol, transport, service, and other industries, covering around 40-45% of the jurisdiction’s total carbon emissions. More than 68 million tons of carbon allowance and offset credits have been traded, with the average price being around RMB 60 per ton of CO2.

The Beijing ETS has proven to be an effective tool to motivate enterprises to adopt emission reduction measures and improve energy efficiency. For instance, since its inclusion as a regulated entity in 2016, the Beijing Public Transport (BPT) has been eagerly replacing  diesel vehicles with electric buses and natural gas buses, and has successfully lowered its diesel consumption by 50% as well as carbon intensity (CO2 per ten thousand kilometer) by 6% between 2016 and 2019. In 2020, BPT has a surplus of 54,000 tons of carbon allowances – which is equivalent to nearly RMB 3 million yuan – indicating that the ETS has not only successfully reduced carbon emissions but has also led to economic benefits for enterprises.

Beijing at COP.png 
The Beijing Public Transport successfully reduced carbon emissions by deploying electric buses.

Li concluded the session with practical takeaways for cities considering to establish an ETS:

  • Regulatory framework and policy design lay the solid foundation of carbon markets;

  • Detailed analyses of historical GHG emissions allow cities to identify key sectors for allowance allocation;  

  • The more capacity building activities covering various aspects are held, the higher possibility that the ETS could operate well and smoothly.

The future looks bright for the Beijing ETS. While the 13 electricity power plants located in the city will be transferred to the national ETS, the remaining entities will continue to be regulated through the municipal ETS. In addition, Beijing is planning to expand the ETS regulatory to further cover the urban logistics and aviation sectors, and is looking to embrace innovative technologies, such as blockchain, to enhance transaction transparency. With innovation and enlarged participation, China’s capital is on its way towards carbon neutrality.

ICLEI East Asia will continue supporting Beijing and other cities in the region to achieve the Paris Agreement goals, as well as to realize the zero-carbon ambition. With ICLEI’s Carbon Neutrality Framework, the in-house experts and consultants at the East Asia Secretariat will work closely with cities in improving GHG inventory methodologies and data quality, divesting from fossil fuels, and offsetting carbon emissions. For more information, please contact iclei-eastasia@iclei.org.

Download the Case Study
Chinese Report Cover.PNG

Kaiser-Friedrich-Str. 7 53113 Bonn Germany
  • T. +49-228/97 62 99-00
    F. +49-228/97 62 99-01
    E. iclei.ws@iclei.org
European Secretariat
Leopoldring 3
79098 Freiburg, Germany
  • T: +49-761/368920
    F: +49-761/3689219
    E: iclei-europe@iclei.org
Brussels Office
Av. de Tervuren 35
1040 Bruxelles, Belgium
  • T: +32 2 735 28 50
    F: +32 2 735 28 50
    E: brussels-office@iclei.org
Berlin Office
St. Oberholz ROS Team Room 4.02, Rosenthaler Str. 72a
10119 Berlin, Germany
  • T: +49 761 36 89 2-0
    F: +49 761 36 89 2-19
    E: berlin-office@iclei.org
Africa Secretariat
3 Knowledge Park, Century City
Cape Town, 8001, South Africa

Postal address:
PO Box 5319, Tygervalley, 7536, South Africa
  • T. +27 21 202 0381
    E. iclei-africa@iclei.org
Canada Office
401 Richmond St. W Studio 204
Toronto, Ontario, M5V 3A8, Canada
  • T: 1-647/728-4308
    E: iclei-canada@iclei.org
Québec Office
Montréal City Hall
275 Notre-Dame St E
Montreal, QC H2Y 1C6
  • T: +1 514 / 793-3300
    E: iclei-canada@iclei.org
British Columbia Office
Victoria City Hall
1 Centennial Square
Victoria, BC V8W 1P6
  • T: +1 250 / 361-0648
    E: iclei-canada@iclei.org
USA Office
1536 Wynkoop St. Suite 901,
Denver, Colorado, USA 80202
  • T: +1 510 844-0699x309
    F: +1 510 844-0698
    E: iclei-usa@iclei.org
Mexico, Central American and Caribbean Secretariat
Eje Central Lazaro Cardenas 13
Building Miguel Abed, Floor 5 Of. 506 and 507, Col. Centro, CP 06050 Del.
Cuauhtemoc, Mexico City, Mexico
  • T: +52 55 5345 3000 xt 5622/5623
    E: iclei-colombia@iclei.org
    E: iclei-colombia@iclei.org
Colombia Office
Área Metropolitana del Valle de Aburrá, Carrera 53 N° 40A - 31
Medellín, Antioquia – Colombia
  • T: +52 55 5345 3000 xt 5622/5623
    E: iclei-colombia@iclei.org
South American Secretariat
Rua Marquês de Itu 70, 14° andar. São Paulo, SP, Brasil
CEP 01223-000
  • T: +55-11 / 5084-3079
    E: iclei-sams@iclei.org
Argentina Office
Boulevard Gálvez, 1150 Planta Alta. Santa Fe, Argentina
  • E: iclei-argentina@iclei.org
South Asia Secretariat
C-3, Lower Ground Floor Green Park Extension New Delhi - 110016, India
  • T: +91 11 4106 7220
    F: +91 11 4106 7221
    E: iclei-southasia@iclei.org
Southern Center
Door No. 6-3-596/47/2
Sri Venkata Ramana Colony
Hyderabad 500 004, Andhra Pradesh
  • T: +91 - 40 / 40034004/5/6/8
    F: +91 - 40 / 40034011
    E: iclei-southasia@iclei.org
East Asia Secretariat
14/F, Seoul Global Center Building, 38 Jongno, Jongno-gu, Seoul, South Korea
  • T: +82-2-3789-0496
    F: +82-2-3789-0497
    E: iclei-eastasia@iclei.org
Beijing Office
B1010 Xiaoyun Center, No. 15
Beijing 100125, China
  • T: +86-10-5712-5289
    E: iclei-china@iclei.org
Japan Office
1-14-2 Nishi-Shimbashi,
Minato-ku, Tokyo, Japan 105-0003
  • T: +81-3/6205-8415
    F: +81-3/3797-1906
    E: iclei-japan@iclei.org
Korea Office
3F, Suwon Research Institute,
126, Suin-ro, Gwonseon-gu, Suwon-si, Gyeonggi-do, 16429, Republic of Korea
  • T: +82-31-255-3257
    F: +82-31-256-3257
    E: iclei-korea@iclei.org
Southeast Asia Secretariat
c/o The Manila Observatory Ateneo de Manila University Campus Loyola Heights, Quezon City 1101 Manila, Philippines
  • T:+63-2/426-0851; 4265921 to 23
    F: +63-2/426-0851
    E: iclei-seasia@iclei.org
Indonesia Project Office
Rasuna Office Park III WO. 06-09 Komplek Rasuna Epicentrum Jl. Taman Rasuna Selatan, Kuningan DKI Jakarta, 12960, Indonesia
  • E: iclei-indonesia@iclei.org
Oceania Secretariat
Level 1, 200 Little Collins Street Melbourne, Victoria 3000, Australia
  • T:+61 3 9639 8688
    E: oceania@iclei.org